He Said, She Said: Wife of deployed Soldier makes for needy neighbor Print E-mail
Wednesday, 09 May 2012

By Mr and Mrs. Smith
Special to GUIDON
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

My neighbor is deployed. He left late last year and has been gone for probably four or five months, but it wasn’t until January that his wife discovered that we’re here.

Suddenly, the woman cannot do anything for herself. It started with her car battery being dead and my husband got it started for her. Then about two days later, she came over and asked if he could help her move a hutch. Next came her asking if he could replace the batteries in her smoke alarm, then replace a light bulb. It has been one thing after another. Sometimes I wonder if she is just lonely, but she never wants to come in and have coffee or tea. It’s always some home improvement project.  Now she wants my husband to plant flowers for her. I think he would do it, but then again, he is never going to say “no.” It’s just not in his nature. He says it’s the least we can do for her deployed husband, but I think it’s moving from help to free labor. I mean really, changing a light bulb? Am I out of line to think this way?

HE SAID: Deployments are hard on everyone, both emotionally and with household chores. If you don’t mind, I think I will cut to the chase here. I don’t really think the free labor is what has you worried; I think you’re probably a little more concerned that she is lonely for male companionship and that she may have ideas about your husband that you’re not comfortable with — which by no means is an unreasonable concern. 

You can take the approach of saying “we’re pretty busy, have you talked to the FRG about having people from your husband’s unit to help,” but I am like your husband in that I enjoy helping people and supporting deployed Families regardless of gender. If you demand your husband stop helping her it will merely serve to create unnecessary tension between the two of you, as he seems to like to help where he can. So, another option, one that I would likely opt for, would be for the two of you to go over and help her out … even if it’s just a light bulb. You can talk to her and keep her company while your husband does the work, or you can all three pitch in. In the process, she will learn some of the skills she may lack, and her calls for assistance will likely diminish substantially.

I would feel I was being disrespectful to my wife if I continually went to a woman’s house to help her out and would feel uncomfortable to be alone in her house while her husband was away. So, this may be a solution that makes everyone feel better about the situation and still lets our deployed Families know we care, we understand, and we are a community that takes care of its own. Think about what you would want if you were in her position — maybe you have been and are just more independent? Don’t misplace your emotions and focus on the wrong issue — that generally just makes you treat the wrong symptom.

SHE SAID:  Given what you have told me, I don’t think you are out of line. I have been on both sides of this issue; being a married woman whose husband helps out a neighbor as well as being a single woman in need of help. Whether you are single, or your husband is simply not available due to deployment or extended duty, there is a line, and I think your neighbor has crossed it. Now, I guess the question is, what can you do about it? Here are your options: Continue to change her light bulbs, clean out her litter box, take out her trash, whatever she asks, with the understanding that this is a temporary situation and when her husband returns, she will no longer need your assistance. I’m not sure this will be the case, as she may continue to look to you, or should I say your husband, to help out when her husband is simply not available.

You can tell her no. Doing this will require your husband to be on board and, from what you’ve told me, I can only imagine that his willingness to help her out without boundaries may be causing some anxiety and frustration. Which brings me to my point —  since your husband is willing to assist her, it is his behavior you have to modify, not hers. He has to be willing to tell her that he is unavailable to help her with routine repairs and if she truly cannot “change a light bulb,” she has a family support group through her husband’s unit that can assist with what she needs.
 This is a predicament, but I fear your biggest mistake, or your husband’s biggest mistake is assuming that it will stop once her husband returns.
 
(Editor’s note: Mr. and Mrs. Smith were both career Soldiers with a combined history of military service spanning over a half of a century. They have been where you are, so if you are facing a difficult situation, ask them. Send your question to This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it . The opinions expressed in this column are those of the writers and not necessarily those of the Fort Leonard Wood Public Affairs Office or the GUIDON.) 
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 23 May 2012 )